Skip to main content

Issues in Law and Medicine A Journal of the Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine - Legal

For Authors

Submit Manuscript

For Authors

Issues in Law and Medicine: A Journal of the Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine (ILM JAHM) publishes peer-reviewed scholarship at the intersection of health care, ethics, and law, with particular attention to the Hippocratic tradition of medicine and the care of the most vulnerable members of our communities. See About the Journal.

This site receives legal manuscripts, including legal scholarship, case synopses, and ethical analysis with a legal focus.
(NOTE: Biomedical research and review articles are submitted through the biomedical submission site.

Legal Article Types

Word counts include footnotes but exclude the abstract and title page. The editors may accept manuscripts outside these ranges when the subject warrants it.

Article type: Article
Length: 10,000–25,000 words
Abstract: Up to 250 words, unstructured
Description: Original legal, policy, or ethical scholarship with a developed thesis.

Article type: Essay
Length: 5,000–10,000 words
Abstract: Up to 150 words
Description: A focused argument on a single question, or a response to recent scholarship or developments.

Article type: Case synopsis
Length: 2,000-5,000 words
Abstract: Up to 150 words
Description: Analysis of a recent judicial decision: facts, holding, reasoning, and significance for medicine, ethics, or law.

Article type: Legislative or Regulatory Comment
Length: 3,000–8,000 words
Abstract: Up to 150 words
Description: Analysis of a pending or recently enacted statute, regulation, or agency action .

Article type: Book Review
Length: 1,500–3,000 words
Abstract: none
Description: Critical review of a recent book within the journal’s scope; Inquire before submitting.

Preparing Your Manuscript

Format. Submit a Word file (.docx), double-spaced, in 12-point type, with footnotes rather than endnotes. Number pages consecutively. Tables and figures go within the text where they are discussed.

Citation style. Legal manuscripts follow the current edition of The Bluebook: A Uniform System of Citation, in footnotes. Where a cited source has a DOI, include it. Manuscripts that rely mainly on medical or scientific literature may use AMA style with the editors’ approval.

Accuracy of authority. Authors are responsible for the accuracy of every citation and quotation. Cite primary sources wherever possible, and give pinpoint citations. Case law, statutes, and regulations should be current as of submission; note any pending appeals or amendments.

Anonymizing for review. ILM uses double-anonymized review: reviewers do not know the authors’ identities, and authors do not know the reviewers’. Remove names, affiliations, acknowledgments, and funding information from the manuscript file, and strip identifying information from the document properties. Refer to your own work in the third person, or replace the citation with “Author citation removed for review.” Full citations are restored after acceptance.

Submission Checklist
REFER TO THIS CHECKLIST AS YOU ARE SUBMITTING YOUR MANUSCRIPTYou will upload these items through the Scholastica portal:

  1. Anonymized manuscript with abstract, footnotes, tables, and figures
  2. Title page (separate file) with title, each author’s name, institutional affiliation, and email, and identification of the corresponding author
  3. Author biographies, up to 100 words each (uploaded in the “additional files” section.)
  4. Cover letter (optional) explaining the manuscript’s contribution and noting any related work under review elsewhere (uploadedd in the “additional files” section)
  5. Competing-interest statement for each author (uploaded in the “additional files” section)
  6. Funding statement, or a statement that the work received no specific funding (uploaded in the “additional files” section)
  7. Research ethics documentation, for manuscripts reporting original research with human participants only (see below)
  8. Supplemental files (optional), such as appendices (uploaded in the “additional files” section)
  9. $10 submission fee, paid at submission

Authorship and Disclosures

Authorship. Each listed author must have contributed substantially to the work, approved the final version, and accept responsibility for its content, consistent with the ICMJE criteria. (https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/browse/roles-and-responsibilities/defining-the-role-of-authors-and-contributors.html)

Others who contributed, including research assistants, belong in the acknowledgments.

Originality. Submissions must be original and not previously published. Notify the editors if the manuscript is under review elsewhere;
ILM does not accept simultaneous submissions.
Disclose any prior publication of substantially similar material, including in a blog, working paper, or report.

Competing interests. Authors and reviewers are required to disclose financial and non-financial competing interests.
• A financial competing interest is any relationship offering the author or close family potential monetary gain or loss depending on the manuscript’s conclusions, including income, equity, gifts, speaking or consulting fees, bonuses, or royalties.
• A non-financial competing interest is any employment, volunteer, advocacy, or litigation role with an organization that may gain or lose depending on the manuscript’s conclusions, including participation as counsel, party, or amicus in a case the manuscript discusses.

A disclosed interest does not imply bias and is not by itself grounds for rejection. The editors evaluate each disclosure individually, and disclosures are published with accepted articles.

Research ethics. Manuscripts reporting original research with human participants, such as surveys, interviews, or analysis of identifiable records, must document approval by an institutional review board or a formal exemption.
Deidentified data base research and doctrinal, historical, and theoretical work does not require this documentation.

AI tools may not be listed as authors, and authors are responsible for verifying every citation and factual statement, including any produced with AI assistance.

ILM JAHM Policies
Editorial and Journal policies are available here: ILM JAHM Policies

Review Criteria

Reviewers assess legal manuscripts on these criteria:
Criterion: Contribution
What reviewers ask: Does the manuscript advance understanding of its subject beyond existing literature, case law, or commentary?

Criterion: Thesis and argument
What reviewers ask: Is the thesis clearly stated early, and does the analysis support it step by step?

Criterion: Accuracy of authority
What reviewers ask: Are cases, statutes, regulations, and medical or scientific sources current, correctly stated, and properly cited?

Criterion: Engagement with opposing views
What reviewers ask: Does the author fairly state and respond to the strongest counterarguments and contrary authority?

Criterion: Interdisciplinary rigor
What reviewers ask: Where the argument relies on medical or scientific evidence, is that evidence represented accurately and with its limitations?

Criterion: Relevance to scope
What reviewers ask: Does the work bear on law, medicine, and ethics as they affect vulnerable persons?

Criterion: Clarity
What reviewers ask: Is the manuscript well organized and accessible to readers in law, medicine, and ethics?

Criterion: Ethical Violation
What reviewers as: Is any confidential or privileged information disclosed in violation of court orders and the duties of professional responsibility?

Editorial Process

  1. The Editor-in-Chief and the Senior Editor for Legal screen each submission for scope and quality, typically within 2 weeks. Manuscripts outside the scope or not ready for review are declined without external review.
  2. The handling editor invites at least two qualified reviewers.
  3. Reviewers return recommendations, typically within 4–6 weeks. The handling editor recommends acceptance, revision, or rejection.
  4. Revised manuscripts should include a response letter addressing each reviewer comment. Revisions are usually re-reviewed by the original reviewers.
  5. The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision .

Authors may appeal a decision by writing to the editors within 30 days with a specific explanation of the grounds.

Fees, Licensing, and Publication

Fees. ILM charges a nonrefundable $10 submission fee. There are no article processing or publication charges.

Copyright and license. Articles are published open access under a [Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY)] license.

After acceptance. Accepted manuscripts are copyedited for style, citation form, and clarity. The corresponding author receives galley proofs and should return corrections within 48 hours; changes at proof stage are limited to errors.

Publication typically follows acceptance by about 3 weeks, depending on length and the author’s responsiveness. Each article receives a DOI.

Corrections and retractions. ILM policy on retractions is modeled after COPE guidance. Errors discovered after publication are corrected through a linked notice. Concerns about a published article may be sent to ILMJAHMAdminEIC@proton.me.

Contact. Questions about submissions: ILMJAHMAdminEIC@proton.me. Status updates on a submitted manuscript are sent through the Scholastica portal.